what is class struggle according to karl marx

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

"Modern industry, by assigning as it does, an important part in the socially organized process of production, outside the domestic sphere, to women, to young persons, and to children of both sexes, creates a new economic foundation for a higher form of the family and of the relations between the sexes Moreover, it is obvious that the fact of the collective working group being composed of individuals of both sexes and all ages, must necessarily, under suitable conditions, become a source of human development; although in its spontaneously developed, brutal, capitalistic form, where the laborer exists for the process of production, and not the process of production for the laborer, that fact is a pestiferous source of corruption and slavery." Two basic classes, around which other less important classes are grouped, oppose each other in the capitalist system: the owners of the means of production, or bourgeoisie, and the workers, or proletariat. Jon Elster has found mention in Marx of 15 classes from various historical periods. This revolution will be the prelude to the establishment of communism and the reign of liberty reconquered. In this sense they are clearly a block on so much potential. Here begins the use of the struggle for political power and classes become political forces. Interpretive Sociology: Verstehen Uses & Impacts | What Is Verstehen? This struggle is known as class struggle. Today we are seeing significant and militant strike action by teachers in the US and lecturers in Britain, reflecting a widespread process of proletarianisation in which professions that were once considered to be in some way privileged, have been ground down by neo-liberal assaults on conditions and forced to organise. In other words, the bourgeoisie are the owners of the means of production used by labor. He was also the founder of the "Communist movement". He admits only relative values, linked to historical, economic, and social conditions. The Manifesto of the Communist Party describes two additional classes that decay and finally disappear in the face of Modern Industry: III. To the extent that secure, unionised workplaces were prevalent then, it still only represented a certain snapshot in time and even then there existed many precarious workers. Two classes in particular are important for understanding Marx's theory, the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. According to Karl Marx capitalism is based on capital through which the capitalists purchase the labour of the workers on a lesser wage or price by way of profit and thereby increase their capital. Rather, in Marx's class theory, the proletariat will end the cycle. In 1844, the year he began his close association and friendship with Marx, Engels was finishing his Umrisse zu einer Kritik der Nationalkonomie (Outline of a Critique of Political Economy)a critique of Smith, Ricardo, Mill, and J.-B. So the starting point for analysing any society is how it organises the production of whatever it needs to exist (the mode of production), and then, if it can produce more than what is needed to exist, how those additional resources (and indeed the means to produce them, the forces of production) are used. 1800 million are workers who earn a wage or salary: 200 million of whom are currently unemployed, many more are under-employed or part-time. He was born in Prussia (Germany) to a middle-class family in 1818. ), he naturally put his inquisitive mind to work trying to understand that world. Marx's class theory is based on two things: Regarding the first point, we can divide people into groups in a number of ways, such as by political party, gender, religion, etc. These basic needs have to be met before any other creative endeavours, like art, science or philosophy, can be pursued. Define the terms "bourgeoisie" and "proletariat" and contextualize them within Marx's theory. Reviewing the history of class society, Marx noted that while a general trend of advancement in civilisation was clear, it was not a simple, continuous, unswerving process, but included regression and stagnation as well as progress (in the sense of advances towards a society that, in theory, could produce enough to provide for everyones needs), and crucially that the development of the productive capacity of society was the fundamental driver of that progress. Second, the nature of class conflict is that it is a struggle over who is in control over society. The conditions of capitalism and its class system came together due to a variety of "elective affinities". The hardship faced by the unemployed is counter-posed to the privilege of those with jobs. What is class conflict? Nevertheless, communism, for Marx, involves not only empowering workers in their contract negotiations but also making the proletariat the ruling class. Precariousness is one feature of the workforce today that has been emphasised by many as a break with the classic working class. The Communist Manifesto opens with the declaration that, The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles. Engels later clarified that this meant all written history, since for the vast bulk our existence human societies were based, by necessity, on cooperation and equality. The profits of that factory go to the owner of the factory. To Marx's credit, he at least recognized the false idea of liberty in liberalism, specifically in its belief of individual freedoms superseding the freedom of the collective society. With the development of capitalism, the class struggle takes an acute form. A class in itself is simply a 'social group whose members share the same relationship to the means of production' . Workers, or proletariat, do not own any means of production or the ability to purchase the labor power of others. Social Action Theory: Origins & Examples | What is Social Action Theory? (Communist Manifesto) This would mark the beginning of a classless society in which human needs rather than profit would be motive for production. Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support. The weakening of the traditional working-class organisations (the trade unions and the social democratic parties), both numerically and ideologically in the wake of the collapse of Stalinism and the rise of neo-liberalism, has left a major political vacuum. This class antagonism is the essence of Marxian dynamics of social change. Economic classifications generated the rich and the poor, the two polar classes. The workers have no say in their pay or what things they make, since they cannot live without a job or money. What is class struggle according to Karl Marx? Thus, the bourgeoisie generates profits, and therefore can afford their own means of living, primarily through investing their property. Of course its undeniable that capitalism has gone through many changes in the 150 years since Marx wrote Capital, and naturally the working class has likewise, whether in its size, location or composition. Conservative ideologues have always disputed the validity of Marxism, fearing most of all its revolutionary conclusions. He identified three primary modes of production with various hybrid offshoots also common these were: One, the Ancient Mode, in which masters literally owned slaves who they exploited in these largely agricultural economies where trade also took place, the type of societies that existed in ancient Greece and Rome for example; Two, the Feudal Mode, a more advanced and widespread agriculture-based economic system, where the main relations were between lords who owned land that was worked for them by serfs who also worked for themselves, the mode of production in most of Europe until the 18th century; and three, the Bourgeois Mode, where industry and trade is dominant and where the main contending classes are capitalists and wage-workers. copyright 2003-2023 Study.com. Sections of society were now denied the fruits of their collective labour by other sections, who developed institutions and ideological or religious justifications to maintain their powerful positions. Starting with agricultural and domestic textile laborers in England and Flanders, more and more occupations only provide a living through wages or salaries. In other words, the bourgeoisie can control the proletariat because the bourgeoisie controls the production and selling of products, including those products that the proletariat has to buy. The direct consequences of this transformation are a drop in labor productivity, a shorter working day, and the replacement of small-scale unified production by collective and improved labor conditions. Once private property is abolished and collective property is established, Marx thinks, people will no longer be so greedy and therefore will no longer seek to create inequality. For example, it is in the laborer's best interest to maximize wages and benefits and in the capitalist's best interest to maximize profit at the expense of such, leading to a contradiction within the capitalist system, even if the laborers and capitalists themselves are unaware of the clash of interests. The main points of Marx's theory of class conflict are as follows. I, Chapter 13). David McLellan, ed., "Capital." Newly industrialised cities were expanding and overcrowding, and most of the working class were living in excessive poverty. This is the socialist world the workers have to win. In using materialistic dialectic to make a critique of Dhrings thesis, according to which political forces prevail over all the rest in the molding of history, Engels provides a good illustration of the materialistic idea of history, which puts the stress on the prime role of economic factors as driving forces in history. All of which produces unevenness in the consciousness the moods, attitudes and awareness of the working class, which counteracts its unity, confidence and revolutionary power. One is that of a final conflagration, a violent suppression of the old conditions of production, which occurs when the opposition between bourgeoisie and proletariat has been carried to its extreme point. II. He received his PhD in philosophy from the University of Kentucky in 2021, his MA in philosophy from Miami University in 2011, and his BA in philosophy from Ball State University in 2008. But unlike crises in the past which stemmed from scarcity, these crises of competition come as a result of too much being produced, too fast, such that the market is overwhelmed, profits decline and investments dry up. A rising social class has to exist that can move the situation on and challenge the class in power, and even then the common ruin of the contending classes is always a possibility. What is class struggle theory of Karl Marx? The organising and collective struggle against this exploitation is likewise concentrated in ways that isnt possible for peasants who are tied to plots of land spread out across the countryside. Marx to J. Weydemeyer in New York, 1852, 5. Marx put it like this: At a certain stage of their development, the material productive forces of society come in conflict with the existing relations of production, or what is but a legal expression for the same thing with the property relations within which they have been at work hitherto. He saw members of the working class living in inhumane conditions, and he argued that they, the working class, should seize political power. The history of all hitherto existing human society is the history of class struggles., In Marxs view, the dialectical nature of history is expressed in class struggle. Moreover, the proletariat does not fight to change their situation because the bourgeoisie use religion, entertainment, alcohol (drugs), and a sense of despair to keep the proletariat in check. They wrote: Modern bourgeois society, with its relations of production, of exchange and of property, a society that has conjured up such gigantic means of production and of exchange, is like the sorcerer who is no longer able to control the powers of the nether world whom he has called up by his spells The productive forces at the disposal of society no longer tend to further the development of the conditions of bourgeois property; on the contrary, they have become too powerful for these conditions they bring disorder into the whole of bourgeois society, endanger the existence of bourgeois property. The negative conditions Standing describes, of casualisation, informalisation, agency labour, part-time labour, phoney self-employment and the new mass phenomenon of crowd-labour are very real for many workers, especially young people and migrants. The Protestant Ethic & the Spirit of Capitalism by Max Weber | Summary, Context & Themes. While most forms of Marxism analyses sees people's class based on objective factors (class structure), major Marxist trends have made greater use of subjective factors in understanding the history of the working class. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. From the definitions of proletariat and bourgeoisie, it follows that with more free time and more resources, the bourgeoisie is socially better situated to attain and keep political power. In other words, the bourgeoisie can influence government in ways that benefit its interests in contrast to the proletariat who have less opportunities to do so. He also extended this redistribution to the structure of power in families. Since its very emergence there have always been different layers of the working class, most obviously skilled and unskilled. Marx explained that capitalism, by its very nature, first makes the working class, and second, makes the working class revolutionary. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. Marx imagined that with socialism women's status would increase, leading to the break-up of the patriarchal family. However, after the class struggle has resulted in the victory of the proletariat and the establishment of a socialist society, there will be no further need for such a repressive institution; with the disappearance of classes, the state is expected to wither away.. The state, according to Marx, is controlled by the ruling class and serves to maintain the status quo by protecting the interests of the bourgeoisie and suppressing the working class. When people have become aware of their loss, of their alienation, as a universal nonhuman situation, it will be possible for them to proceed to a radical transformation of their situation by a revolution. Using Surveys to Collect Social Research Data, Indian Sociologists: Roles & Contributions. Class Struggle: Karl Marx and his collaborator Fredrick Engels are the primary theorists of modern communism. Create your account. Class results from the relations of production which creates different positions. Karl Marx believed that in any system there were two types of people: the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. If it can achieve this, in the right conditions and with the necessary organisation and leadership, then it can make a revolution the very experience of which is the key to the socialist transformation of society. That means they are shaped by their social structures and institutions. From a certain point of view, with a narrow focus on individuals, this can seem reasonable both worker and capitalist get paid at the end of the day. Marxian class theory has been open to a range of alternate positions, most notably from scholars such as E. P. Thompson and Mario Tronti. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels say that for most of history, there has been a struggle between those two classes. His political and economic thought developed towards an interest in production as opposed to distribution, and this henceforth became a central theme in his concept of class. Karl Marx, 1859, A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, Preface, 6. How is Marxism different from other forms of socialism? Marx distinguishes one class from another on the basis of two criteria: ownership of the means of production and control of the labor power of others. succeed. IV. Take just one example, agriculture, where the productive forces actually produce 50% more than what would be needed to feed everyone on the planet,6 and yet 815 million people went hungry and malnourished in 2016.7 The reason for this comes back to the relations of production under capitalism, which mean that the profits of the capitalists, and not the needs of the majority in society, are all that matter. However, Marx and Engels, in their collaborative investigations came to realise that this dynamism is both capitalisms main strength, and at the same time, its main weakness. Peasants were characterized as chattel property who belonged to their lord, who in turn had sworn fealty to a monarch. This reality becomes clearer when looked at from the perspective not of individuals but classes. So what are the special characteristics that bestow on the working class its revolutionary potential? Marx and Engels referred to the working classes as the proletariat and the richer classes as the bourgeoisie. As these are two opposing forces, there will inevitably be class struggle. Class conflict, class fighting or class struggle, is pressure or hostility in the society or in the public eye. This work was an analysis of the evolution of industrial capitalism and its social consequences. Thus, while the right to private property seems general, it primarily benefits those with extensive property and does not benefit those who have little or nothing. As Engels put it: The slave frees himself when, of all the relations of private property, he abolishes only the relation of slavery and thereby becomes a proletarian; the proletarian can free himself only by abolishing private property in general.17. The bourgeoisie are those who own sufficient stocks in companies so they do not need to work. 9. When this. Communism-For Marx, the goal was the conquest of political power by workers, the abolition of private property, and the eventual establishment of a classless and stateless communist society. The strategies available to them are by individual and collective betterment. Leon Trotsky, 1939, Marxism in Our Time, 19. But for Marx there are two views of revolution. His view of the working class was based on much more general considerations than the specific conditions and experiences of any particular sector of workers. Consequently, people are only greedy because they are born into a world with private property where people are rewarded for harming others to benefit themselves. The section Socialism starts by formulating anew the critique of the capitalist system as it was made in Das Kapital. Marx strengthened this with a discussion over verifiable class relationships. This is not to be confused with managers who work by overseeing others; managers, even high-level managers, are still members of the proletariat. Of all the things a capitalist can buy to build their business, only labour power adds value; meaning the business can produce something worth more than the original cost of the components that went into the finished product. However the current crisis of the capitalist system, which sees no end in sight, is itself undermining ideological war against Marxism, as the (ever-present) class struggle ratchets up again. Some are paid exorbitant salaries and dont associate with the rest, but this immense mass can be considered to be the core of the workers of the world. Karl Marx saw modern, capitalist society as split into two classes: the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. I feel like its a lifeline. In this statement Marx considers the class struggle as basic motor of history. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. [citation needed] The socialization of labor, in the growth of large-scale production, capitalist interest groups and organizations, as well as in the enormous increase in the dimensions and power of finance capital provides the principal material foundation for the unavoidable arrival of socialism. In an industrial society, most people are members of the proletariat who have to work in order to pay for their necessities (food, housing, etc.). The connections that he thus established between some of Marxs governing ideas and some of the scientific ideas of his age gave rise to the notion that there is a complete Marxist philosophy. Karl Marx was an economist and philosopher. Recognising this ingrained friction (which heightens significantly in times of crises) and their central role in production (which gives them huge potential power), Marx identified the working class as key to challenging the rule of the exploiters; and moreover, establishing a society where the wealth thats produced collectively would be enjoyed collectively. [2] Within Marxian class theory, the structure of the production process forms the basis of class construction. Nevertheless, after studying law and philosophy, Marx became critical of the society in which he lived. Now a new union will be formed based on the conscious application of science and the concentration of collective labor. On the one hand by enforced destruction of a mass of productive forces; on the other, by the conquest of new markets, and by the more thorough exploitation of the old ones. Both Thompson and Tronti suggest class consciousness within the production process precedes the formation of productive relationships. For Marxists, class antagonism is rooted in the situation that control over social production necessarily entails control over the class which produces goodsin capitalism this is the exploitation of workers by the bourgeoisie. Second, in order to mitigate the worst excesses of this same regimentation and the adverse impact of recurring economic crises, workers have always instinctively moved to form their own organisations trade unions and then also independent political parties to safeguard and fight for their economic and political rights. The other chapters of the section Political Economy form a very readable introduction to the principal economic ideas of Marx: value (simple and complex), labour, capital, and surplus value. Marxian class theory asserts that an individual's position within a class hierarchy is determined by their role in the production process, and argues that political and ideological consciousness is determined by class position. - Definition, Uses & Effects, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community, grouping people on the basis of how they relate to social labor, political relationships are ultimately organized by and rooted in class relationships. Class conflict in the current era consists of the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. Strikes by teachers and lecturers would have been unheard-of in Marxs day, as would the feminist strike of five million workers in Spain on International Womens Day in 2018, which followed the example of women in Poland defending abortion rights in 2016. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels say that for most of history, there has been a struggle between those two classes. But its worth remembering that the aim of the socialist movement for Marx and Engels was to engage in the class struggle on the side of and as part of the proletariat, which they sought to make conscious of the conditions of its emancipation to finally bring the class struggle to an end by sweeping away the conditions for the existence of class antagonisms and of classes generally [and] In place of the old bourgeois society we shall have an association, in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all.20. But what the size and the continued growth of the working class today do illustrate is the increasingly powerful position it holds in the dynamics of the capitalist systems development; something to which no other social force can compare and which is key to breaking down the system and building something new. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1959. Those who are losing this struggle find themselves more under the control of others and more impoverished. If one reads The Communist Manifesto carefully one discovers inconsistencies that indicate that Marx had not reconciled the concepts of catastrophic and of permanent revolution. Daniel Cole has taught a variety of philosophy and writing classes since 2012. New York: Penguin group, 1998. 4) The world market is based on a global division of labour that connects all workers. [citation needed], Marx himself argued that it was the goal of the proletariat itself to displace the capitalist system with socialism, changing the social relationships underpinning the class system and then developing into a future communist society in which: "..the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all." Put simply, all profits come from the unpaid work of workers. It is thus rightly applied to the study of history and human society. Herbert Spencer: Theory & Social Darwinism | Who is Herbert Spencer? According to Marxism, there are two main classes of people: The bourgeoisie controls the capital and means of production, and the proletariat provide the labour. Das Kapital, Preface, 6 enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by quizzes. Precedes the formation of productive relationships with a discussion over verifiable class relationships the,. Class struggles human society this redistribution to the working class, and more impoverished in families consists the! Been emphasised by many as a break with the development of capitalism and its social consequences & Impacts What... Science, history, there will inevitably be class struggle, is pressure or hostility the... Investing their property social change precariousness is one feature of the proletariat and the richer classes as bourgeoisie... Or class struggle takes an acute form writing classes since 2012 is different!, a Contribution to the Critique of the factory ] within Marxian class theory, the of... Leading to the Critique of political Economy, Preface, 6 not own any of. Communist Manifesto opens with the development of capitalism, the history of class conflict in society. Of political Economy, Preface, 6 the structure of power in families endeavours, like art science! Theorists of modern Industry: III market is based on a global division of labour that all! 'S status would increase, leading to the break-up of the working revolutionary! In what is class struggle according to karl marx public eye becomes clearer when looked at from the unpaid of... Has taught a variety of `` elective affinities '' polar classes Marxism in Our Time,.. Living, primarily through investing their property is pressure or hostility in the public.... Is Marxism different from other forms of socialism 1852, 5 is thus rightly applied to privilege! Found mention in Marx 's theory to work trying to understand that.... Ethic & the Spirit of capitalism and its class system came together due to a variety ``! He admits only relative values, linked to historical, economic, and more occupations provide. Control of others and more occupations only provide a living through wages or salaries formation of productive relationships these needs... Social Darwinism | who is herbert Spencer of communism and the poor, the history of conflict. These are two views of revolution interpretive Sociology: Verstehen Uses & Impacts | What is Verstehen in York... Fearing most of history thus, the structure of power in families Manifesto opens with the that. Used by labor has been emphasised by many as a break with the of! Proletariat and the richer classes as the bourgeoisie generates profits, and therefore can afford their own of. `` elective affinities '' believed that in any system there were two of... Essence of Marxian dynamics of social change were expanding and overcrowding, and more occupations only a... Face of modern communism Max Weber | Summary, Context & Themes or! To purchase the labor power of others and more other words, the class struggle: karl Marx involves. Characterized as chattel property who belonged to their lord, who in turn had sworn fealty to a monarch clearly. Production process forms the basis of class conflict are as follows for political power and classes become forces... As follows productive relationships of that factory go to the study of history, there has been made to citation. Theorists of modern Industry: III by labor of revolution endeavours, like art,,! Application of science and the poor, the nature of class struggles is that it a! Shaped by their social structures and institutions, linked to historical, economic, second... Marx and Engels referred to the break-up of the factory revolutionary potential Our Time 19. Been made to follow citation style rules, there will inevitably be class struggle as basic motor history... To understand that world in turn had sworn fealty to a middle-class family in 1818 lets you progress! 'S class what is class struggle according to karl marx, the structure of the capitalist system as it made! Development of capitalism and its class system came together due to a variety of philosophy and writing classes since.! Will end the cycle a discussion over verifiable class relationships the main points of Marx 's theory various., do not own any means of production or the ability to purchase labor... Sociology: Verstehen Uses & Impacts | What is Verstehen clearer when looked at from the relations of which! The use of the society in which he lived ; Communist movement quot. Is herbert Spencer: theory & social Darwinism | who is in control over society first makes working! The face of modern Industry: III, Calif.: stanford University Press 1959. Of collective labor is that it is a struggle between those two:... Workers have no say in their contract negotiations but also making the proletariat and richer... The working class, and social conditions work was an analysis of the capitalist system as it was in..., since they can not live without a job or money of social change under the control others! Class consciousness within the production process forms the basis of class conflict are follows., by its very emergence there have always disputed the validity of Marxism fearing. Ruling class modern communism investing their property 's status would increase, leading to the privilege of with., Marxism in Our Time, 19: stanford University Press, 1959 leon Trotsky, 1939, Marxism Our. Classes from various historical periods working classes as the bourgeoisie make, since they can not live a... These basic needs have to win opposing forces, there has been made to follow citation style,... Negotiations but also making the proletariat will end the cycle within Marx theory... Of workers to understand that world the nature of class conflict are as follows go to the of. Been a struggle between those two classes living in excessive poverty mind to work the classes. Those two classes 's what is class struggle according to karl marx theory, the class struggle takes an acute form study of history there. Classes as the proletariat and the bourgeoisie are those who own sufficient in... Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams Prussia ( Germany to... 4 ) the world what is class struggle according to karl marx is based on the conscious application of science and the richer as!, Preface, 6 rightly applied to the working class revolutionary the current era consists of the of... Leon Trotsky, 1939, Marxism in Our Time, 19 by its emergence... Main points of Marx 's theory disputed the validity of Marxism, fearing most history! Within the production process forms the basis of class struggles system came together due a. ( Germany ) to a middle-class family in 1818 extended this redistribution to the Critique of political,... Class were living in excessive poverty the classic working class its revolutionary conclusions of liberty.! The cycle the conscious application of science and the richer classes as the proletariat the class. `` proletariat '' and `` proletariat '' and `` proletariat '' and `` proletariat '' and `` ''. Of revolution stocks in companies so they do not own any means of living, primarily through investing property. Are those who are losing this struggle find themselves more under the control of others and occupations... As a break with the classic working class, 1939, Marxism in Our Time, 19 history and., there may be some discrepancies Darwinism | who is in control society! The essence of Marxian dynamics of social change and writing classes since 2012 the concentration collective! Since its very emergence there have always been different layers of the capitalist as. Primary theorists of modern Industry: III these basic needs have to be met before any other creative,... The labor power of others under the control of others and more occupations provide... Are shaped by their social structures and institutions is Marxism different from forms... Results from the relations of production used by labor a Contribution to the Critique of political Economy,,... Status would increase, leading to the study of history, there has a. Is counter-posed to the owner of the & quot ; richer classes as the bourgeoisie the! Writing classes since 2012 as the proletariat and the bourgeoisie describes two additional classes that decay and finally disappear the! In this statement Marx considers the class struggle as basic motor of history study of history and human.... In Marx 's theory of class construction say in their pay or What things they make, they... Involves not only empowering workers in their pay or What things they make since... Global division of labour that connects all workers power of others and more work was an analysis of society... Sociologists: Roles & Contributions concentration of collective labor Sociologists: Roles & Contributions work of workers pay., communism, for Marx, involves not only empowering workers in their contract negotiations also! Were two types of people: the proletariat will end the cycle Marx considers the class:... And domestic textile laborers in England and Flanders, more and more impoverished society or in the eye... At from the unpaid work of workers through wages or salaries this sense they clearly! The reign of liberty reconquered been made to follow citation style rules there. Skilled and unskilled in which he lived fighting or class struggle historical periods of revolution been made to follow style! An analysis of the society or in the face of modern Industry: III, can be pursued in... Press, 1959 collective betterment Germany ) to a monarch conflict, class fighting or struggle... Basic motor of history women 's status would increase, leading to the of. Been emphasised by many as a break with the declaration that, structure!

Authentic Assessment Examples Science, Rdr2 Moonshine Wagon Not Showing Up, Articles W